Message-ID: <11615eli$9805271528@qz.little-neck.ny.us> X-Archived-At: From: Lee Vine Subject: Rogue Reviews Digest No. 1 - May 25, 1998 Newsgroups: alt.sex.stories.d,alt.sex.stories.moderated,alt.sex.stories Followup-To: alt.sex.stories.d MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Path: qz!not-for-mail Organization: The Committee To Thwart Spam Approved: X-Moderator-Contact: Eli the Bearded X-Story-Submission: X-Original-Message-ID: <3568F8A9.E9B0907@switchboardmail.com> RRD No. 1 =========================== NOTES: (1) IF YOU ARE UNDER 18 THEN STOP READING NOW!!!!! (2) IF YOU ARE OFFENDED BY DESCRIPTIONS OF NATURAL ACTS WHICH SOME PEOPLE CALL PLEASUREABLE BUT YOU REGARD AS NECESSARY FOR THE PERPETUATION OF THE HUMAN RACE THEN STOP READING NOW!!!!!!! (3) IF YOU AREN'T SURE IF EITHER (1) OR (2) APPLY TO YOU THEN STOP READING NOW!!!! =========================== Rogue Reviews Digest No. 1 - May 25, 1998 by Lee Vine Contents Reviews Rogue Review No. 23 [Letters by Darkside] Rogue Review No. 24 [French Kisses by Sandman] Rogue Review No. 25 [Behind the Curtain by Ann Douglas] Rogue Review No. 26 [Cannon Song by Miles Naismith] Rogue Review No. 27 [Becky Cried by Poison Ivan] Rogue Review No. 28 [A D&S Fairy Tale by Tigger] Rogue Review No. 29 [One O'Clock Jump by Taria] Rogue Review No. 30 [Taxi Tales: Missed Connections by Delta] Note 1: Taking a suggestion from someone on ASSD I have decided to start publishing my reviews several at a time instead of individually. Note 2: If you are interested in receiving my reviews individually you can join my mailing list (Sex Stories Discussion List). I have set it up not just for my own reviews, but for anyone else who wants to post their reviews or thoughts about any stories found on Alt.Sex.Stories.Moderated or any of the other ASS newsgroups. Note 3: If you want to find out more about why I it set it up when there already is a newsgroup for that purpose then I recommend you read the essays I posted to ASSD, "ASSD: An Experience" and "Seven Conclusions from a Heated Debate". These can also be found on my home page. Note 4: There is a form for joining the Sex Stories Discussion List on my home page. Home Page - http://www.geocities.com/Paris/Cafe/3112/ ====== Rogue Review No. 23 - May 21, 1998 Letters by Darkside M/F, tg, transform Length: 7,900 words Summary Jennifer and John's mother passes away. She leaves some letters for them to read. They discover some startling facts about their parents. Commentary I enjoyed this story. It was melodramatic to the point of being whole wheat. The melodrama added humor. The plot was good, simple but entertaining. The characters were a bit wooden, but then I consider that normal seeing as it was a melodramatic story. There was an occasional sentence with a word out of place. The sex was a bit forced, although the way it was introduced did make me laugh. With a more work I think this could have been an excellent story. Rating I give this story a 7 on a scale of 10. ====== Rogue Review No. 24 - May 22, 1998 French Kisses by Sandman M/F, M/F/F Length: 9,700 words Summary Jean-Claude grows up in France during World War Two. He learns about sex from his sister and his father's mistress. He goes on to further sexual adventures. This was a companion piece to Janey's April by Janey. Commentary I read Janey's April and did not like it. I was not sure what to expect. I was pleasantly surprised. French Kisses is a beautifully told story. There were a handful of episodes. They all flowed together nicely. Sandman took a story of Janey's that I felt was lacking, among other things, any redeeming values and breathed real life into it. There was no real plot, other than the sexual education of a young Frenchman. Jean-Claude radiated warmth. Mary and Alice, seemed just as sex starved as in the Janey's April, but that did not ruin the story, because neither of them was relating the story. I liked the main character. The sex was not forced or encyclopedic. Best Line: "I removed my penis and began the soft, rhythmic strokes that had always brought me such pleasure." (Yeeeees!! Pinky, are you pondering what I'm pondering?) (I think so, Brain, but do you really want to be an intern at the White House? I mean think about it. Long hours, private meetings with the president, hard work, private meetings with the president, wearing berets, private meetings with the president.) (Hmmmm, you may have a point there, Pinky. If there's one thing I can't stand its a wearing a beret.) Rating I give this story a 8.5 on a scale of 10. ====== Rogue Review No. 25 - May 23, 1998 Behind The Curtain by Ann Douglas F/F Length: 16,000 words Summary Annette gets a promotion and some time off. The only thing she can think about is hot, lesbian sex. She gets it, but from a woman she never thought about getting it from. Commentary This was a good story. Most of the sex scenes were well placed with appropriate lengths, but there was one that seemed a little too long. It really could have been a story unto itself, but maybe I am missing the point, because it did reveal certain facts about Annette's past. The descriptions, narration, characters, etc. were all well done. The dilemma did not really enter the story until towards the end. I prefer it to be introduced a little earlier, but it was well handled. Rating I give this story a 7 on a scale of 10. ====== Rogue Review No. 26 - May 24, 1998 Cannon Song by Miles Naismith M/F Length: 5,000 words Summary In the Spring of 1969 three couples decide to blindly swap partners and see what happens. Commentary Wow. That was good, damn good. There was definitely tension in this story. There are six characters in the story, but I only felt like I knew three of them when I was done reading it. (That is just an observation not a criticism.) The story seemed real enough. Nothing in it felt forced. It was both arousing and touching. Rating I give this story a 10 on a scale of 10. ====== Rogue Review No. 27 - May 24, 1998 Becky Cried by Poison Ivan M/F, Exhib Length: 5,000 words Summary Voyeurism and exhibitionism. Commentary This was an excellent story. Ivan did not tell us too much, or too little. The descriptions were marvelous. The tension was there. The story was very well written. The author did a great job of leaving details for the reader to fill in with his/her own imagination. It was arousing, but it also had a sensitive side to it. Rating I give this story a 10 on a scale of 10. ====== Rogue Review No. 28 - May 24, 1998 A D&S Fairy Tale M/F, F/F, D/S, Magic, Con? Length: 31,400 words Summary Christiana is a mistress who in the past has treated some of her subs rather badly. One man in particular, who loves her very much, was almost driven to suicide. Adrian, a wizard, casts a spell on Christiana. She has to make it up to those she has hurt by playing the sub for them. Until she does so she will not be released from his spell. Commentary This story was well done in certain ways. The sex was well placed, and very arousing. I found the descriptions and the situations that the main character got herself into to be its strengths. If you are not turned on by dominance and submission then you might not want to read this one. There is some cross-dressing and quite a bit of bondage and discipline. Most of the sex was consensual. The scenes where the character is placed under a spell are kind of iffy. She knows what she is doing, but she does not have complete control, but she does seem to enjoy it. I am not sure if there is any non-consensual sex in this story, but I am also not convinced that there is not any non- consensual sex in this story. The plot is rather simple and straight forward. The characters are each distinct. In some ways I think this story was supposed to be touching, but it did not touch me. The narration was a bit mechanical and I could not feel the emotion, it seemed a bit artificial. I still liked this story. Tigger did a good job of mixing various elements and keeping the plot moving. If you intend to read this story, I advise reading it in parts. It is long. I found it much better to stop at the end of each episode and take a break. I do not think I would have enjoyed it as much if I had tried to read the whole thing in one sitting. Rating I give this story an 8 on a scale of 10. ====== Rogue Review No. 29 - May 25, 1998 One O'Clock Jump by Taria M/F Length: 4,200 words Summary A man and a woman meet, dance, and fuck; in that order. Commentary The rhythm of this story is amazing. The way Taria wrote it you can just feel the beat jumping through it. It probably would have helped if I had put on some appropriate music, but even without music Taria's descriptions made this story shake, jump, and dance. Strictly speaking this story is not about sex or love or even pleasure. It is about a drum beating out a frenetic pace, a horn section hypnotizing all that can hear its siren call, and a throng of hot sweaty people moving with their hearts and praying that the night will never end. That was a poor job of trying to imitate Taria's style in this story, but I could not help myself. I just finished reading it and the music is still inside me. I can hear it now. The drums beating (dum, dum, DUM, dum, dum), the horns wailing, and the people dancing. This story was so much fun to read. I do not claim to be objective usually, and this time I am not even going to attempt to be. I just loved this story. Was it really a story? I think so. It had all the necessary elements, but as long as I let its pace carry me I find it extremely hard to be objective. You never cease to amaze me Taria. Rating I give this story a 9.5 on a scale of 10. ====== Rogue Review No. 30 - May 25, 1998 Taxi Tales: Missed Connections by Delta M/F Length: 3,800 words Summary Dale does not care for guys who chew out their women in public. He gives one of his fares a hard time for doing so. Later the woman thanks him. Commentary I really like Delta's work at creating Dale. In some ways he seems a bit caveman-ish, but there is also an integrity about him that is very appealing. The story is simple, but well told. The sex is simple, and honest. There was not much to dislike about this story. It was a very good story. Rating I give this story a 9 on a scale of 10. -- Lee Vine Its not easy being green. -- Kermit the Frog ________________________________________________________ | | E-Mail - santiago@switchboardmail.com | | Home Page - http://www.geocities.com/Paris/Cafe/3112/ |________________________________________________________ -- +----------------' Story submission `-+-' Moderator contact `--------------+ | | | | Archive site +----------------------+--------------------+ Newsgroup FAQ | ----